Ever since the Arab Spring, the world’s political status quo has been challenged, and the United States of America —still the globe’s only true superpower (maybe China will be there soon, but not now)— is still trying to figure out its role in this changing political landscape. While the Obama Administration was slow to recognize the Cairo revolution, it was quicker to respond to Libya. But what about Syria or Bahrain? And of course, what about Palestine?
Now, my position about Israel and Palestine is very similar to the views of many of my Israeli and Palestinian friends: a peace that will ensure security and co-existence for both countries. The violent views of extremists have no place in the dialogue. I don’t choose this view for religious reasons (unlike US evangelicals who believe that for the End of Days to come, all people of Jewish descent must first head back Israel before the second coming of the Messiah) nor do I use history to justify why there should be peace in the Middle East. The reality is that every human, every country, has a right to self-determination, which last time I checked, was a basic tenet of America’s Founding Fathers when a new country revolted against the English Crown in the late 18th century.
What intrigues me about Palestine’s recent attempts to seek statehood from the United Nations is that they had the cojones to just go for it. Sure, such a move did not play well in Tel Aviv, but what is even more surprising is that it didn’t play well with President Obama either. What does that tell you about the United States? Self-determination is only encouraged when it fits the interests of the United States. So, sorry, Syria and Palestine, no dice. But Libya? Sure, you can determine your own destiny.
So what can Puerto Ricans, whose country in essence is the Western Hemisphere’s oldest colony, learn from what Palestine is trying to do and Washington’s reaction to it?
In the end, no matter how determined Puerto Rico is to finally resolve its 113-year-old political status paradox (are we a colony, a commonwealth, the 51st state of the Union, an independent country, or a freely associate state), San Juan is still subservient to Washington. Puerto Ricans and their politicians (all of them, from the pro-statehooders to the Populares to the Independentistas) have failed the island. Our system is broken. Politicians on the island are programmed to serve their own party’s interests, instead of working together to promote a new way to determine Puerto Rico’s political paradox. Instead of following the bold (and some critics would say disrespectful) steps of Palestine, Puerto Ricans stay silent and wait, passive for others to make changes for them.
What is to stop us Puerto Ricans from forming our own non-partisan UN committee to demand that we finally determine our political status? Airline tickets from San Juan to New York are not that expensive, why can’t we go to the UN and say, “We have had enough NON-BINDING plebiscites about our status, it is time for the world community to support our intent to finally resolve our political status, no matter what that final vote is?”
Are we afraid of Washington? What would Washington do? Remove our federal benefits? Get rid of our Wal-Marts and Costcos? Why can’t we begin to work together and speak as one Puerto Rico and demand that the world finally pay attention to us?
Instead, we remain passive. We rely on a political system that for over 50 years has exploited us with dreams of free countries or adding another star to the American flag. Add the 60 years before the new Constitution was formed, and it is clear: our current ways to determine our future are not working.
So, to my fellow Puerto Ricans, will we go to the UN? (NOTE: I am very aware that resolutions from the UN have been brought up and been passed, but nothing has happened. I am suggesting a more bolder non-partisan delegation that DEMANDS support and gains the global attention it deserves.) Will we actually practice self-determination, or will we continue to be the colonials that we are? You know, the ones who would rather rely on Washington so as not to offend the federal government. While others fight, we stay silent.
As Republican presidential candidate John Huntsman so eloquently said this week in Orlando: America should worry about America. Will Puerto Rico begin to worry about Puerto Rico? Only we can answer that question. Nothing can stop us. Nothing.





A thoughtful and though-provoking essay, Julio. Well done.
Great post, Julio. The powers that be on the Isla have to come to their senses and realize that all the bickering among themselves has taken them no where. As if the world beyond theirs does not exist. It is long overdue for them to put that all aside, remove the strings attached and truly represent the Puerto Rican nation…in one common role..that road, is the road to self determination via the type of action you mention. Peace.
Am wondering if this could start out of the mainland with our own elected reps since they have the vote and the resident commissioner doesn’t
I think people need to realize how important the US is to the US and Puerto Rico will never be in its priorities.
Great Post Julio.
Exactamente, hermano.
One major difference between the move to self determination for a Palestine vs Puerto Rico is that Puerto Rico isn’t threatening the existence of its neighbors. Puerto Ricans aren’t lobbing missiles daily in efforts to instigate their neighbor into fighting. Yet, as the author says, America only cares about its own interests.
Good point, yet I think I was approaching this from a more philosophical perspective. Why can’t PR just take the case aggressively to the international community? Why are we waiting for permission from the United States.
“What intrigues me about Palestine’s recent attempts to seek statehood from the United Nations is that they had the cojones to just go for it. Sure, such a move did not play well in Tel Aviv, but what is even more surprising is that it didn’t play well with President Obama either.” Julito
Even if the UN had been able to give Palestine what they wanted, their own sovereign nation, there would still be many problems to solve between Israel and Palestine before it could happen. Territory is still in dispute for one. President Obama saw Palestine as trying to circumvent the negotiations with Israel and sneak in the back door via the UN. Anyone remember when President Clinton resided over talks with Sharon and Arafat at Camp David? Sharon gave Arafat 99% of what he wanted, and still Arafat turned down the offer. Why? Because his bluff was called by Sharon. Arafat and the Palestinians do not want peace with Israel. They want Israel wiped off the face of the earth. How do you negotiate with people like this? You can’t.
I’m sure the UN would like to see some sort of Constitution outlining this new and bold sovereign Puerto Rico. That would be a very constructive step in getting this moving in the right direction. Anyone writing one yet? Bold talk needs to be backed up by a bold plan so the average citizen can see what it is they would be committing themselves to.
“A good leader takes the people where they want to go. A great leader takes the people where they need to go.” Unknown Author
The first thing you have to do is opt for your Puerto Rican citizenship and renounce the US citizenship. After that the road is clear. Stand up and walk the
talk.